场所认同的多元性与时间性:对当代中国场所认同建构的批判
Pluralism and Temporality in Place Identity Revisited: A Critique of Place Identity Construction in Contemporary China
作者:陈峥能 Zhengneng CHEN
摘要
在当今全球城市化浪潮中—尤其在城镇化如火如荼的中国,场所的加速变迁令当代城市陷入认同危机。在这一背景下,本文探讨了当代中国快速城镇化进程中对场所认同的概念建构。在回顾和审视中西方社会科学和设计专业中有关场所认同的主要理论和研究后,本文提出将场所认同的哲学概念理解为一种多元性和时间性建构。基于这一理念,本文通过三个案例进一步指出了中国场所认同建构实践中存在的问题。这些案例试图从不同维度出发,展现对当今中国场所认同建构的复杂性的全景式解读。整体而言,本文认为在中国的城镇化实践中,场所认同的建构应当将认同诉求的多元性和时间性、多重尺度,以及场所认同随时间的改变全部纳入考量。对中国城镇化进程中的场所认同问题的研究,不仅是对近年来快速城镇化的批判性思考,同时也是对当下千余座正在经历及可能经历城镇化的村镇的前瞻性关照。
关键词
场所认同;多元性;时间性;理论建构;中国;城镇化
Abstract
The trend of global urbanization has put the contemporary cities in identity crises by accelerating place transformations, particularly in the thriving ground of China. This paper explores ways of conceptualizing place identity in relation to rapid urbanization in contemporary China. After a revisit of the main theories and studies on place identity from both the social sciences and design professions (in China and the West), the paper asserts a philosophical concept of place identity as a pluralistic and temporal construct. Drawing on this philosophy, the paper provides further observation and critique upon place identity construction praxis in China through three case studies. These cases together approach a holistic reading of the complexity of place identity construction in China today. Taken as a whole, the paper argues that construction of place identity in China’s urbanization should account for its pluralism and temporality in identity claims, multiple scales, and transformation of identity through time. The study of place identity issues in China’s urbanization leads to a critical reflection on not only the rapid urbanization of the recent past, but also that taking place now and likely to occur in more than a thousand small towns and villages in the future.
Key words
Place Identity; Pluralism; Temporality; Theoretical Construct; China; Urbanization
集合地域:面向弹性地方未来的公共艺术实践
Collective Territories: Public Art Practices for a Resilient Localization
作者:孙沐阳 Moya SUN
摘要
本文通过跨学科的实践案例,探讨了公共艺术作为一种非传统景观形式,在应对由全球化与本土建设之间的脱节而造成的一系列社会与生态问题时所发挥的作用。三个案例均从自然地理与生态概念入手,通过将社会、文化和经济现象投射到地球的物质空间特征当中,强调了个体与全球大系统之间互为表里的关系。在这些实践中,特定地域的公共艺术作为一种实践工具,提供了意识与功能相调和的多媒介平台,通过场地干预激发了更加广泛的质疑、批判、宣言和行动等。而公共艺术的开放性亦为城市设计及其他众多行业共同探讨如何开拓可持续的地方未来提供了更多可能。
关键词
全球大系统;特定地域的公共艺术;集合地域;解域;再结域
Abstract
In this article, art works as unconventional landscape interventions are introduced, showing the interdisciplinary practices in responding to social and ecological issues brought by the rupture of global activities and local geographies. Started from natural geology and ecology, these public art works emphasize the close connection between individuals and the global system by coupling social, cultural, and economic phenomena with the physical foundation of the earth. In these practices, site-specific art is functioning as a tool to create intermediate spaces between mind and function, where questions, critics, manifestos, and actions, take forms through site interventions. The openness of these practices stimulates more dialogues among multiple industries about the sustainability of localization.
Key words
Global System; Site-Specific Art; Collective Territory; Deterritorialization; Reterritorialization
从珠江三角洲城中村实践探索中国城市发展模式
Exploring China's Urban Development Pattern through Practice of Urban Village in the Pearl River Delta
作者:孟岩 Yan MENG
摘要
本次访谈围绕中国的城市发展问题展开。受访人孟岩介绍了URBANUS都市实践建筑设计事务所长期以来对城市的观察和思考,并以深圳城中村为切入点探讨了怎样的城市才是充满活力、具有都市性的健康城市。此外,他希望通过2017深港城市/建筑双年展突破观念和边界的桎梏、建立交流机制,并探索未来可能的新的城市发展模式。孟岩认为设计师只有先成为一个观察者、思考者、研究者,才能更好地回应一个地区的独特语境和文化特征。
关键词
城市;城中村;双年展;发展模式;研究;实践
Abstract
This interview centers on the urban development issues faced by most Chinese cities. Yan Meng, Principal Architect and Co-founder of URBANUS Architecture and Design, shares his perspective on cities, and discusses what kinds of cities are dynamic, lively, and healthy by taking urban village in Shenzhen as an example. Besides, as one of the curators, he hopes that the 2017 Shenzhen Bi-city Biennale of Urbanism / Architecture can offer an opportunity to break boundaries, foster communication and exchange, and explore new urban development pattern in the future. Meng also believes that architects’ roles as an observer, a thinker, and a researcher could allow them to better respond to the unique context and cultural characteristics of a site as a designer.
Key words
City; Urban Village; Biennale; Development Pattern; Research; Practice
“一专一村”计划:基于推动农村内源性发展的本地实践
One University One Village Program: Promoting Endogenous Development in Rural Areas through Local Practice
作者:万丽 Li WAN
摘要
本次访谈围绕中国西部农村地区生土建筑实践展开。受访人万丽以“一专一村”农村可持续发展支援计划的突出实践之一—云南光明村震后重建示范项目为例,阐述了建造工作中的难点和突破点,并就在不同地区开展生土建筑的异同及其应用前景进行了阐释。此外,通过详细介绍“一专一村”计划的工作模式及流程,受访人强调设计师应当尽力解决社会实际问题,承担力所能及的社会责任。“一专一村”计划希望通过持续的本土化探索,为世界其他具有生土建筑传统的地区提供案例参考,并唤醒民众及设计师的本土意识。
关键词
农村;震后重建;生土建筑;“一专一村”计划;本土化;全球视野
Abstract
This interview is centered on the practice of earth architecture in rural West China, starting from introducing the post-earthquake reconstruction project in Guangming Village, Yunnan Province, as an outstanding example of the practice of the “One University, One Village” Rural Sustainable Development Assistance Program. Li Wan, the interviewee, explains the differences of design consideration and the difficulties in practicing earth architecture throughout China, while giving her prospect on its future application. Through a further introduction on the operation and project procedure of the Program by Wan and her team, the interviewee addresses that architects should take their responsibilities on solving social issues, with a hope that, through their site-based efforts, the Program could provide a global paradigm to similar earth architecture practices in other regions, rousing designers’ awareness of localization.
Key words
Rural Area; Post-earthquake Reconstruction; Earth Architecture; One University One Village Program; Localization; Global Vision
全球挑战与地方实践:将城市打造为包罗万象的生态系统
Global Challenges, Local Solutions: The City as an Ecosystem of Events
作者:汤姆·里瓦德,迈克尔·考迪,钱昱 Tom RIVARD, Michael COWDY, Jack QIAN
摘要
在这个全球危机四伏的时代,城市不仅是社会进步的载体,也是体现多样性和灾难应对弹性的核心区域。面对日趋紧张的气候、社会、生态和经济环境,McGregor Coxall设计事务所更关注人们建造自己城市的过程和背后的故事。我们的项目对于这些指导城市建设的环境特性秉承辩证的态度:我们认同城市是经济增长的引擎和文化产业的市场,但必须将建成环境区别于“自然”的这种认知却未免荒谬。
当代城市的成就建立在全球发展和环境影响这两种压力相互矛盾的关系之上。为解决二者带来的危机,McGregor Coxall设计事务所同时聚焦于两种尺度下的设计实践:着眼于区域范围内的经济发展和生态系统运作的大尺度规划,以及关于人、街道和街区的小尺度设计。系统性的设计思想为我们的项目提供了经济和环境层面的实施框架,而对社区需求的切实考量则保证了我们能够为每个项目制定真正因地制宜的设计方案。
关键词
生物都市主义;弹性;绩效;公众参与;叙事;社区
Abstract
In a time of global challenges, cities are critical not only as vehicles for progress, but also as centers of diversity and resilience. Confronted with intensifying climates, and social, ecological, and economic issues, McGregor Coxall focuses on the stories people tell in making their cities. Our projects accept and challenge these stories which underpin city-making: the engine of economic progress, the marketplace of cultural production, and the myth of our separation from “nature.”
The success of contemporary city is built on a paradoxical relationship with two pressures: global development and environmental impacts. To address these crises, McGregor Coxall works at two scales, simultaneously, on all of our projects: in the large-scale realm of regional economic development and ecosystemic operations, and at the scale of the person, the street, and the neighbourhood. The systemic understanding provides the contextual basis by which projects perform, economically and environmentally, while our understanding of communities makes each project a genuine product of its time, place, and culture.
Key words
Biourbanism; Resilience; Performance; Public Engagement; Narrative; Community
“五水共治”示范工程:金华市浦阳江生态廊道
Restoring the Mother River back to the City: Puyangjiang River Corridor in Jinhua
作者:俞孔坚,俞宏前,宋昱 Kongjian YU, Hongqian YU, Yu SONG
摘要
作为浙江省“五水共治”(治污水、防洪水、排涝水、保供水、抓节水)的示范工程,浦阳江治理修复项目将原本遭受严重污染的河道转变为了广受市民喜爱的生态廊道。项目从水生态修复入手,引入由小型滞留湿地和大型湿地斑块组成的湿地净化系统,使水质得到显著改善。设计体现了海绵城市建设理念和最小干预策略,在提升场地应对洪水的弹性的同时,将设计对原有自然环境的扰动降至最低。此外,项目对场地原有的农业、水利和文化历史遗迹进行了保护、激活并巧妙改造,赋予了场地艺术与教育价值。
关键词
湿地;生态净化;海绵城市建设;最小干预;历史遗迹
Abstract
As a pilot project of water treatment in Zhejiang Province, the Puyangjiang River Corridor project has remediated the polluted river course into a popular ecological and recreational corridor. The project restored the aquatic ecosystems and improved the water quality by introducing a constructed wetland system which purifies the irrigation water and the tributaries of Puyangjiang River. Under a concept of Sponge City construction and a minimal intervention strategy, the design not only enhances the flood resilience, but also minimizes the disturbance to natural ecosystems of the site. In addition, the existing agricultural, water-conservational, and cultural heritages have been preserved and partly reused as recreational structures and facilities, contributing aesthetic and educational values to the site.
Key words
Wetland; Ecological Purification; Sponge City Construction; Minimal Intervention; Historical Heritage
应对城市问题的本土设计—曼谷都市森林公园
Local Design Responding to the Urban Problems — The Metro-Forest Project, Bangkok
作者:曼谷景观设计事务所 Landscape Architects of Bangkok
摘要
曼谷都市森林项目旨在反映曼谷昔日的景观、应对各种城市问题,并增加城市森林面积。该项目在优先选择传统乡土树种的同时,采用宫胁生态造林法,以创造多样性的森林生态环境并促进植物生长。此外,设计团队对各种树种的布局以及栽植密度也进行了精心安排。空中步道和观景台的设计不仅可以在森林演替的初期最大程度地减少游人对迅速生长的树林的干扰,也使人们有机会近距离欣赏成熟的林冠之美。通过对曼谷本地设计语言的巧妙运用,这里成为了一处真正能够唤醒公众环境保护及城市森林意识的公共空间。
关键词
城市森林;乡土树种;树种演替;林冠;教育
Abstract
To respond to the urban problems and to increase forest areas in the city, an urban forest reflecting Bangkok’s former landscape was designed and constructed. To create diverse forest ecology and stimulate plant growth, Miyawaki’s ecological method to reforestation was implemented, and local tree species were used for pioneer planting as they had once established territorial populations around Bangkok. The layout of the species was carefully grouped, and planting locations were also carefully selected. The skywalk and observation tower were designed to minimize disturbance of the burgeoning forest and allow close-up views of the maturing canopy. This project is distinguished by strong design gestures that are well integrated into the landscape by using Bangkok’s design language, creating a space truly to inspire public awareness of urban forestry and the importance of environmental stewardship in Thailand.
Key words
Urban Forest; Local Tree Species; Succession of Tree Species; Canopy; Education
童年的记忆—瑞士日内瓦梅林区雕塑景观设计
L’enfance du Pli (The Fold’s Childhood) — A Sculpture-Landscape Design in Meyrin of Geneva, Switzerland
作者:吉利斯·布鲁塞特 Gilles BRUSSET
摘要
设计与建造行业对于效率与标准化的追求,往往以牺牲场所感知为代价。“童年的记忆”项目以雕塑景观的形式,为日内瓦邦迪斯地区创造了一个具有深远意义和影响的设计作品。通过展现侏拉山脉自然的景观地貌,该项目向现代化的建筑理念发出了挑战,并对梅林园区体现出的对原有景观的漠视做出了回应。
关键词
雕塑景观;场所认同;空间性;地形;艺术
Abstract
Increased efficiency in the design and construction of standardization is often accompanied by a loss of perception of the site. L’enfance du Pli (The Fold’s Childhood) is a sculpture-landscape, monumental and elongated in Boudines, Geneva. In a form of interpretating the force that spawned landscapes of the Jura Massif (Jura folds), the project challenges the principle of modern architecture and responds to the ignorance of the pre-existing landscape that presided over the realization of the Meyrin Park.
Key words
Sculpture-Landscape; Place Identity; Spatiality; Topography; Art
现在,重新激活萨拉热窝—波斯尼亚和黑塞哥维那历史博物馆改造设计
Reactivate Sarajevo Now — The Regeneration Design for the Historical Museum of Bosnia-Herzegovina
作者:阿尔弗雷多·伯莱姆博,休伯特·克拉姆皮尼,哈里斯·皮拉斯,瑞士联邦理工学院U-TT建筑与都市主义实践事务所 Alfredo BRILLEMBOURG, Hubert KLUMPNER, Haris PIPLAS, Urban-Think Tank, ETH Zurich
摘要
在激进的变革时代,我们需要将城市视作实验性机遇,而萨拉热窝这座城市却绝无可能成为这样的“城市实验室”。但是,正如全球许多当代城市一样,萨拉热窝动荡的城市建设更迭史及其建成环境中的多层社会、文化及政治印迹使挑战与机遇在这座城市中并存。萨拉热窝断层式的政治、社会和历史发展使其成为了一座拼凑城市。通过突显萨拉热窝既有的当地社会文化和生态系统,U-TT建筑与都市主义实践事务所的“重新激活萨拉热窝”项目不仅有助于这座作为波黑首都的城市的战后复兴,还可以透过其非凡的经验,在更广阔的意义上为全球相关实践提供借鉴。
关键词
激进都市主义;城市实验室;断层式开发;激活;战后复兴
Abstract
In times of radical change, we need to look into cities as laboratories. A sheer unlikely candidate for such an urban laboratory is the city of Sarajevo. Yet, the city’s turbulent past of alternating periods of construction and destruction and the variety of social, cultural, and political layers in its built environment reveal challenges and potentials relevant to the state of many contemporary cities around the globe. Sarajevo’s discontinuous political, social, and historical development has created a bricolage city. By highlighting the existing local socio-cultural and ecological systems, the Urban-Think Tank’s “Reactivate Sarajevo” project aims not only to contribute to a post-war revitalization of the Bosnian capital but also to produce, from the experience of this extraordinary city, lessons of wider, possibly global significance.
Key words
Radical Urbanism; Urban Laboratory; Discontinuous Development; Reactivation; Post-war Revitalization
气候变化对文化景观之影响:以美国太平洋沿岸地区国家公园为例
Climate Change Impacts on Cultural Landscapes: A Preliminary Analysis in U.S. National Parks across the Pacific West
作者:罗伯特·Z·梅尔尼克,诺亚·P·克尔 Robert Z. MELNICK, Noah P. KERR
摘要
本文阐述了俄勒冈大学文化景观研究小组的一项研究,分析了关键气候变量可能对美国国家公园系统中太平洋沿岸地区文化景观造成的影响。本研究旨在在气候变化的背景下确保国家公园系统文化景观弹性,并为未来的相关研究提供借鉴。
关键词
文化景观;气候变化;国家公园;全球性问题;风险;脆弱性
Abstract
The study of climate change impacts on cultural landscapes in the Pacific West Region of the National Park System by the University of Oregon’s Cultural Landscape Research Group, assessed how these landscapes might be affected by key climate variables, and developed recommendations for future research toward the agency’s goal of ensuring cultural landscapes’ resilience in light of climate change variables.
Key words
Cultural Landscapes; Climate Change; National Parks; Global Issue; Exposure; Vulnerability
海洋农业:未来食物景观
Agro-Pelago: Foodscapes for the Future
作者:贾克林·卡洛奇 Jaclyn KALOCZI
摘要
如果景观设计师能够在海洋中耕作、生产食物,那将会是怎样一幅图景?受持续增长的人口数量、资源需求,以及气候变化危机的影响,未来沿海地区的农业用地终将面临枯竭。海平面上升致使农田被海水淹没,不可持续的耕作方式消耗着岌岌可危的土壤资源,传粉昆虫和作物变种现象屡见不鲜,耕地逐渐被城市用地占领,粮食安全无从谈起—这样的现象正在世界各地发生。这些全球性威胁为景观设计提供了重新构想未来食物景观的机会。“海洋农业”项目最终以叙事动画影片的形式呈现,讲述了全球食品安全面临的挑战,并提出了针对特定地区的解决方案。
关键词
食物景观;农业;水产养殖;气候变化;弹性
Abstract
What if landscape architects could cultivate the sea to produce food? In the future, rising populations and the demand on resource consumption alongside the crisis of climate change leave agricultural land in coastal areas facing extinction. Across the globe, rising sea levels causes farmland flooded by salt water, unsustainable farming depletes soils, pollinators and crop varieties increase, and as land transforms from arable to urbanized, food security disappears. These world-wide threats present opportunities for landscape architecture to re-envision food landscapes for the future. Presented through an animated and narrated film, Agro-Pelago addresses global food security challenges while implementing local solutions.
Key words
Foodscapes; Agriculture; Aquaculture; Climate Change; Resilience
灰水利用的契机—对境外水域的探寻与思考
When the Only Water Left Is Gray — The Growing Quest for Foreign Watersheds
作者:托马斯·尼德律斯特 Thomas NIDEROEST
摘要
干旱地区约占陆地总面积的41%,承载着全球三分之一的人口,更有多个特大城市坐落其中,以丰富的矿产和肥沃的土壤创造了每年数十亿美元的经济收入。然而,持续的人口增长与不断变化的降水量造成了水资源的严重短缺。为在维持当地经济稳定发展的同时有效进行人口增长的预测,世界各地的政府纷纷将水-能网络扩展到境外流域中。作为由哈佛大学查尔斯·艾略特旅行奖学金资助的比较设计研究项目的一部分,本文探讨了全球范围内的水资源短缺问题。项目研究了旱灾对干旱地区的影响,记录了不同区域水系统的特征,概述了大型水利工程对社会经济与社会生态的影响。通过呈现这些过程,本文从景观设计学的角度探讨了当前的水资源议题,通过强调灰水的重要性而将视野从“水之稀缺”向“水之充沛”转变。为印证这一具有社会和经济复杂性的构想,该项目通过国际案例研究探讨了中央集控下跨境调水的缺陷以及地方分控下灰水收集及利用的潜力。为应对水资源短缺的问题,跨尺度且多样化的干预措施不可或缺;以景观过程为框架的混合系统的建立,成为了跨学科规划与设计的关键。
关键词
水资源短缺;干旱;资源充沛模式;非中心化;基于景观的方法
Abstract
Arid regions around the world comprise approximately 41 percent of the global surface area. These drylands are inhabited by 1/3 of the global population, are home to several mega-cities and nurture a multimillion dollar economy annually. However, continuous population growth and changing precipitation patterns created the phenomenon of water scarcity. To stabilize the local economy and facilitate population growth projections, governments around the world extend their water-energy-network to access foreign watersheds. As part of a comparative design research project under the Harvard based Charles Eliot Fellowship, this article addresses the global issues of water scarcity. It studies the effects of drought in arid regions, documents territorial water systems and outlines the socio-economic and socio-ecological effects of megaprojects. By revealing these processes, the article discusses the current water discourse from the perspective of landscape architecture and endorses a paradigm of abundance. To illustrate this complex social and economic proposition, a survey of international case studies provides the understanding of the territorial gap and demonstrates decentralized action on a local scale. Ultimately, to challenge water scarcity, a plurality of interventions at multiple scales are inevitable. The key for interdisciplinary planning and design lays in the hybridity of systems, which are framed by a landscape-based approach.
Key words
Water Scarcity; Drought; Paradigm of Abundance; Decentralization; Landscape-Based Approach
用以塑造视野的影像散文
The Video Essay as Geomorphic Tool
作者:乌苏拉·比曼 Ursula BIEMANN
摘要
近年来,我的影片所关注的尺度已经从全球拓展到星球范围。为探寻这一由非人类参与者扮演重要角色的新视角,我实地考察的焦点也转向了偏远地区,那里脆弱的生态系统正承受着全球资源开采业带来的巨大压力。在本文中,笔者将通过《深度气候》(2013)和《森林法则》(2014)两部影片,阐述如何以影像散文的形式来创作超越其自身意义的景观。在两部影片所展现的影像环境保护主义论述中,自然物质以及物理和气候过程不再作为叙述社会事件的戏剧化背景—这些从幕后走到台前的主角,承载着人与地球之间脆弱、复杂、诗意而又极度实体化的关系。
关键词
影片;当代叙事手法;资源开采;气候变化;部落社会;生态危机
Abstract
In recent years, my videos have performed a shift from a global to a planetary scale. In pursuit of this new perspective where nonhuman actors begin to play an important role, my fieldwork has taken me to remote territories where fragile ecosystems have come under great pressure from the global resource extraction industry. In this article, I elucidate the two video works, Deep Weather (2013) and Forest Law (2014), to demonstrate how I use the video essay to create landscapes that are imbued with meaning beyond themselves. In the cinematic environmentalism these videos present and matter, physical and climatic processes no longer provide a dramatic backdrop for the narration of social events; they have moved to the fore to play the leading role, forming a world in which the human-Earth relationship is fragile, complicated, poetic, and intensely physical.
Key words
Video; Contemporary Narratives; Resource Extraction; Climate Change; Indigenous Communities; Ecological Crisis